Esther McCarthy - New Beginning

Published Monday 19th February 2007
Esther McCarthy - New Beginning
Esther McCarthy - New Beginning

STYLE: Pop
RATING 6 6 6 6 6 6
OUR PRODUCT CODE: 21535-12106
LABEL: Independent
FORMAT: CD Album
ITEMS: 1

Reviewed by Lins Honeyman

This debut release from Esther McCarthy sees the English singer/songwriter team up with producer and multi instrumentalist Andrew Rayner to showcase a collection of worship songs. Coming from a background of leading worship, McCarthy stated in a recent interview that it was her intention to put together a collection of original songs aside from ones that are usually used in worship sessions. This aim has certainly been fulfilled given that all but one of the tracks here are McCarthy originals. Included in this category is the opener "In This Place" which sets the tone of worship for the whole album. However, proceedings fail to sufficiently get off the ground mainly due to the fact that the lyrical content of each song lacks variety. The vast majority of songs are presented from a singer to God perspective - there is absolutely no doubting McCarthy's heart for worshipping God through her songs - but a more flexible approach to presenting God's glory would ultimately enhance her material. McCarthy's style is accessible and easy to listen to and, whilst her voice occasionally lacks power, Andrew Rayner's production sustains and underpins the album. Although the pace is pretty much the same throughout, 'New Beginning' reaches new heights on two occasions. The first being the glorious "One Name" in which Congolese vocal group Quatuor Yimbila add a much needed depth that is lacking elsewhere. Secondly, the bonus track "Come To Me" is a great little electronic piece arranged by James Phillips and sung from the perspective of God calling out to someone far from him. McCarthy could do worse than to emulate the freshness and diversity of these two tracks on her next recording.

The opinions expressed in this article are not necessarily those held by Cross Rhythms. Any expressed views were accurate at the time of publishing but may or may not reflect the views of the individuals concerned at a later date.

Interested in reviewing music? Find out more here.

Reader Comments

Posted by Elaine Brooks in Bury St Edmunds @ 19:38 on Feb 25 2007

I was disappointed to read a rather negative review of New Beginnings. Proceedings might have failed for you - but not for me and hundreds who have Esther's CD and enjoy every minute. Variety transverses every sphere of spirit & natural man. I pray for God to increase your receiving levels! Flexible is Esther. She moves with incredible ease and talent - from easy listening (in this place) ballad (Hadassah's song, her testimony) jazz ( I've got it all) rock (one name) and the funky My Everything and in between a variety of worship songs I can now sing along to and make my own! Nothing about this CD lacks power. Her voice is clear and sweet. The pace is not the same throughout! Take a little more time, Lins to listen. I have listened to it many times now and I have never been tempted to skip or jump tracks - each one is a gem and different! Esther has produced with the help of a small team with restaints that bigger music teams do not work under to produced an amazing CD. You don't have to point out the limitations! It's her first CD and it's simplicity. Remember Amy Grant's My Father's Eyes? Listen to that again and you will find a rawness of new beginnings as well - but the talent and gifting was there. Esther is a gifted singer/songwriter with great talent and did you read the dedication on the back cover? She humbly gave it to God as a gift and shared it with you and me. Listen to it again as her Christian sibling first and critic second. Put away those wrong judgments! She will bring much more to us in the years to come and God's prosperity will cut her free from the restraints she was under in her first recording. Esther! Hold your head up high and wear God's cloak of honour. Do not be disheartened go forth and create as God wills - not man.



The opinions expressed in the Reader Comments are not necessarily those held by Cross Rhythms.

Add your comment

We welcome your opinions but libellous and abusive comments are not allowed.












We are committed to protecting your privacy. By clicking 'Send comment' you consent to Cross Rhythms storing and processing your personal data. For more information about how we care for your data please see our privacy policy.